Published On November 19, 2026
Author Stephen Ramkissoon
Categories
Email Marketing
What CASL requires of your marketing emails: consent rules, required content, unsubscribe timing, a compliance checklist, penalties and how it differs from GDPR.

Canada’s Anti-Spam Legislation (CASL) says you may not send a commercial email to anyone unless they have consented, either expressly or by implication, and the message carries your identity, your contact details and a working unsubscribe mechanism. Section 6(1) of the Act sets that rule, and the burden of proving consent sits with you, the sender. For a small business without a full-time marketing team, the practical answer is to treat consent records and email templates as part of your marketing system from the first campaign, and to have a team running that system that builds compliance into every send.

This guide explains the rules in plain terms, shows what a compliant email and a compliant list look like, and gives you a checklist you can work through this week. It is general information, not legal advice. If you are unsure whether a specific practice is lawful, such as a purchased list or a complex referral programme, take it to a Canadian lawyer who handles marketing law.

TL;DR

  • CASL applies to any commercial electronic message (CEM) sent to or from Canada, including email, SMS and other messages to mobile devices.
  • You need express or implied consent before sending, and you must be able to prove it with records.
  • Every message must identify the sender, include contact information and offer an unsubscribe mechanism; unsubscribe requests must be honoured within 10 business days.
  • Express consent does not expire until withdrawn; implied consent runs out, typically after two years from a purchase and six months from an inquiry.
  • Penalties can reach $10 million per violation for an organization, and directors can be personally liable.

Table of Contents

Who CASL covers and what counts as a commercial message

A commercial electronic message, or CEM, is a message sent to an electronic address that encourages participation in a commercial activity. A newsletter promoting your services, a discount announcement and a product launch email all qualify. According to the CRTC’s FAQ, CASL covers email, SMS and other messaging to mobile devices. The CRTC (Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission) is the regulator that enforces the main email rules.

Location does not get you out of it. The same FAQ states that CEMs sent to recipients in Canada from other countries must comply, and that messages sent from Canada to recipients abroad are generally covered too when they are sent using a computer system located in Canada, subject to a limited exemption for certain listed jurisdictions with similar rules. If you are a Canadian startup selling to the United States, or a US company selling to Canadians, CASL is part of your compliance picture.

Messages that do not need consent

Some messages are exempt from the consent requirement. Sections 6(5) and 6(6) list them. Among them are messages between people with a personal or family relationship, messages that are solely an inquiry or application about a commercial activity, and messages that only:

  • provide a quote the recipient requested;
  • complete or confirm a transaction the recipient already agreed to;
  • give warranty, recall or safety information;
  • send factual notifications about a subscription or account;
  • deliver a product, good or service, including updates.

These transactional messages are the exception, not a loophole. The moment you add a promotion to an order confirmation, it starts to look like a marketing message, and you should treat it as one.

Consent: express and implied

Consent is where most small businesses get into trouble, because the rules are narrower than many marketers assume. The CRTC recognizes two types of consent: express and implied.

Express consent means the person clearly agreed, in writing or orally, through a proactive opt-in action. According to the CRTC’s guidance, it is not time-limited until the person withdraws it. A pre-ticked box is not a proactive opt-in. The same guidance notes that an email asking for express consent is itself a CEM, so you cannot use a marketing email to collect consent you do not already have.

Implied consent arises from specific situations: an existing business relationship, an existing non-business relationship, or an address that the recipient has conspicuously published without a statement that they do not want unsolicited messages, where your message is relevant to their role. The CRTC guidance describes implied consent periods of two years after a purchase and six months after an inquiry. For a subscription or membership, the period starts when the relationship ends, as the CRTC’s 2014 publication on consent explains.

Situation Type of consent How long it lasts
Visitor ticks an unticked box on your sign-up form Express Until they withdraw it
Customer buys from you Implied (existing business relationship) Typically two years from the purchase
Prospect sends you an inquiry or application Implied Six months from the inquiry
Ongoing subscription or account Implied Clock starts when the relationship ends
Address found online, no relationship None unless conspicuous publication rules are met Not a safe basis for marketing

A worked example: a Saskatoon landscaping company sells a spring cleanup to a homeowner in April. That sale gives it implied consent to send promotional emails for about two years. A second homeowner fills in the quote form in April but never buys. The company can email that person for six months, after which it needs a proper opt-in to continue. If either person ticks a newsletter box on the website, the company now holds express consent and the clock stops mattering.

Be careful with scraped and bought addresses

The Gowling WLG CASL guide reports that in the Compufinder case the Federal Court of Appeal required the sender to show, with admissible documentary evidence, how it gathered consent. Gowling reads the decision as signalling that implied consent should be interpreted narrowly, and that a recipient’s job title alone is not enough to show a message relates to their role. Mining addresses from directories is the pattern the law is aimed at.

If you work with a list supplier or an outside marketing firm, the Office of the Privacy Commissioner advises asking in detail where the addresses came from, how consent was obtained and how the list is kept current, with the terms set out in a contract. PIPEDA, the federal privacy law, requires informed consent to collect and use electronic addresses even when they come from a third party.

What every marketing email must contain

Consent is only half the rule. Under section 6(2), each message must:

  1. Identify the sender, and the person on whose behalf it is sent if that is someone else.
  2. Include contact information that lets the recipient readily reach one of those persons. Section 6(3) requires that this information stay valid for at least 60 days after the message is sent.
  3. Set out an unsubscribe mechanism that works.

The exemptions in section 6(6) remove only the consent requirement. A message that falls under an exemption can still need to meet the content requirements, so build the footer into your template once and use it everywhere.

A practical footer includes your legal business name, a mailing address, a monitored reply email address or phone number, and a visible unsubscribe link that works without a login. Test it on mobile, since a link that is tiny or hidden is a common reason requests get missed.

Handling unsubscribe requests

No matter what type of consent you hold, once someone asks to stop receiving CEMs, the CRTC’s guidance says you must stop within 10 business days. That applies whether the person uses your unsubscribe link or another channel, such as replying to an email, writing on social media or phoning your office.

That last point is where small teams slip. The person who monitors the inbox is not always the person who manages the email platform. Decide who owns unsubscribe requests, set up a rule so that replies saying “remove me” reach that person, and update your suppression list the same day. Doing it faster than 10 business days is simple when it is automated, and it keeps you well inside the rule.

A CASL compliance checklist for your next campaign

The CRTC’s compliance guidance points senders to obtaining consent, running an ongoing compliance program, reviewing policies and keeping accurate records of consent, training and third-party contracts. Turned into steps:

  1. Map your lists. For every contact, record where the address came from and the date.
  2. Label the consent type. Mark each contact as express, implied from a purchase, implied from an inquiry, or exempt, and store the date the implied period ends. Keeping separate segments by consent type makes it easy to stop mailing contacts whose implied consent has lapsed.
  3. Capture evidence. Keep sign-up form screenshots, subscription logs with timestamps, the wording shown at opt-in and the contact’s email address. The CRTC’s 2016 enforcement advisory states that the onus of proving consent always stays with the sender, and it recommends keeping records of consent evidence, how you collect consent, your CASL policies and procedures, and all unsubscribe requests and what you did about them.
  4. Clean the forms. Opt-in boxes unticked, one clear statement of what people are signing up for, and your identity stated.
  5. Standardize the footer. Sender name, contact information valid for 60 days and a working unsubscribe link in every template.
  6. Set the unsubscribe workflow. One owner, one suppression list, a target of the same or next business day.
  7. Schedule list expiry. Review the list regularly and remove or re-permission contacts whose implied consent has expired.
  8. Write a short policy and train your team. The CRTC notes that a corporate compliance program can reduce the likelihood of a violation and help establish a due diligence defence.
  9. Document third parties. If an agency, freelancer or platform sends on your behalf, put consent handling and list sourcing in writing.

If you want a closer look at how consent and automation fit together in a sales funnel, our piece on lead scoring for Canadian small businesses shows how CASL shapes follow-up timing.

CASL compared with GDPR

If you also sell to Europe, you will run into the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). They overlap but are not the same. According to a Bennett Jones comparison, GDPR consent must be freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous. CASL requires consent to send a CEM unless an exemption applies, sets formalities for valid express consent, limits implied consent to prescribed cases and places the onus of proof on the party claiming consent.

The practical gap is that GDPR has other lawful bases beyond consent, while CASL for commercial email is built around consent first. If you meet CASL’s opt-in standard and keep strong records, you will already be close to what most European regulators expect from email consent, but you should confirm GDPR obligations separately for any European audience.

Penalties and who enforces CASL

Three federal bodies share enforcement. The Office of Consumer Affairs explains in ISED’s overview that the CRTC can issue administrative monetary penalties (AMPs) for violations of sections 6 to 9, the Competition Bureau deals with false or misleading representations and the Privacy Commissioner focuses on address harvesting and illegal collection of personal information.

The maximum AMP is $1,000,000 per violation for an individual and $10,000,000 per violation for an organization, and directors and officers who directed, authorized or took part in a violation can be held liable. In the CRTC’s process, a notice of violation typically comes with a penalty, and the recipient usually has 30 days to pay or submit written representations.

Enforcement is active. ISED’s 2024–25 CASL report states that in that year the CRTC issued 260 Notices to Produce, 33 Warning Letters and 14 Preservation Demands, along with over $137,000 in AMPs. Most large cases involve missing consent, broken unsubscribe links or poor sender identification, and most of those could have been prevented by the records and templates described above.

 

CASL enforcement actions and AMP total in 2024–25

The private right of action, which would let individuals sue senders directly, is not in force, but you should not plan around that. The regulator’s powers are enough on their own.

Our perspective: compliance is a marketing system, not a legal afterthought

Most small businesses we meet treat CASL as a legal footnote they will deal with after the campaign is built. We see it the other way around. Consent is the foundation of an email programme, and a list built on clear opt-ins performs better and carries less risk than a larger list nobody can account for.

That is why we build marketing for each client around their own goals and audience instead of dropping them into a generic template. A custom plan means the sign-up forms, the lead magnets, the email footers and the reporting are designed together. The same dedicated strategists who plan your content and your campaigns can look at where your contacts come from and how they are recorded, and our clear, actionable reporting keeps the numbers that matter in front of you, so you are not operating in the dark.

Because our subscription is flexible and contract-free, you get the equivalent of a marketing team without full-time hires. Email works best when it is connected to SEO, content, social media and paid advertising, so each channel feeds a list that you have permission to contact.

Stephen Ramkissoon

Getting email, content and consent working together

A compliant list does not grow on its own. It comes from content people want, a website that makes signing up simple and campaigns that give subscribers a reason to stay. Marketing Guardians is a subscription-based marketing agency that covers SEO, PPC advertising, social media management, content creation, web design and development, analytics and reporting, conversion optimization and strategy, all on recurring monthly plans without a long contract.

If you want a team that plans your email marketing alongside the rest of your marketing, with each strategy custom-built for your brand and goals, start with our services overview. If you are comparing agencies, our guide on choosing a marketing agency in Canada and spotting CASL and PIPEDA risks lists the questions to ask about list sourcing and consent. For follow-up that triggers automatically once someone opts in, see our marketing automation service.

 

Marketing Guardians

To talk through what a monthly plan would look like for your business, visit Marketing Guardians.

FAQ

Does CASL apply to B2B email?

Yes. CASL covers commercial electronic messages whether the recipient is a consumer or a business. A message sent to a work address that promotes a product or service needs consent unless an exemption applies. Implied consent from a conspicuously published business address is narrow, and a job title alone is not enough to rely on.

How long do I have to honour an unsubscribe request?

The CRTC’s guidance says you must stop sending CEMs within 10 business days of the request, whichever way the person asks. In practice, process it the same day through your suppression list so no scheduled campaign reaches them.

Can I email people who bought from me years ago?

Only while implied consent lasts. Typically that is two years from the purchase. After that, you need express consent, so invite past customers to opt in through your website, at checkout or in person rather than by email, because a request for consent sent by email is itself a CEM.

Is CASL stricter than GDPR?

For commercial email, CASL is built around prior consent and puts the burden of proof on the sender, with implied consent limited to listed situations. GDPR offers other lawful bases in addition to consent. If you send to both regions, meet the stricter requirements of each.

What records should I keep?

Keep proof of how and when each contact consented, the form wording, subscription logs, unsubscribe requests and the actions taken, your CASL policies and any staff training records, as recommended in the CRTC’s enforcement advisory.

Sources

Recommended

 

Which Question Do You Want Answered About Your Business?

Here Are Four Free Tools, That Will Give You Straight Answers

Reading about visibility is helpful, but seeing your own numbers is even better. Marketing Guardians built four free tools that each answer one clear question about how customers find your business. You can check whether AI tools recommend you, spot the gaps in your content, understand where your website visitors come from, and see how you show up on Google Maps in your own neighbourhood.

Every tool takes just a few minutes and gives you a plain picture you can act on right away. If you are not sure where to begin, start with Picked By AI, and run the others whenever you are ready.

Free tools · A few minutes each
Which question do you want answered?

Pick one. Each tool is free to try and shows you a different piece of how customers find your business.

Start here

Picked By AI

Does AI recommend my business?

See whether AI tools name you when customers ask for a provider, and which competitors they name instead.

Check my AI visibility

Content Roadmap

What should we write about next?

Spot the gaps in your topic coverage and get a focused, month-by-month content plan.

Build my roadmap

Insight Compass

Where do my website visitors come from?

Turn your traffic into a plain-English picture of what is working and what deserves a closer look.

Read my traffic

Local Map Rank

Do people nearby find me on Google Maps?

See how you rank across 25 spots on a colour-coded map, plus a report with three prioritized next steps.

Show me my map

Not sure where to begin? Start with Picked By AI. You can always run the others later.

You May Also Like

No related posts found.

Back To Top